AU pulling out of International Criminal Court is bad: Justice Emile Short

The International Criminal Court (ICC) is not targeting African countries as “misconceived” by the African Union (AU), Justice Emile Short has said.

At its February summit in Addis Ababa, the AU said member states must pull out of the ICC to send a message to the international community to stop “harassing” Africans.

A withdrawal strategy adopted by members, read: “A growing number of African stakeholders have begun to see patterns of only pursuing African cases being reflective of selectivity and inequality”.

It was put together by a ministerial committee (made up of foreign ministers of Kenya, Ethiopia, Chad, Burundi, Eritrea, South Sudan, Kenya, Libya, Sudan, Madagascar, Namibia, Zimbabwe and Senegal) formed after the African Union summit in Johannesburg in 2015.

The committee’s formation followed after South Africa rejected an ICC order to arrest Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir who was wanted for war crimes in Darfur. South Africa subsequently notified the UN of its withdrawal intention.

The Gambia, under Yahya Jammeh’s presidency withdrew from the ICC but his successor Adama Barrow has reversed that move.

Also, not all member states are in favour of pulling out of the ICC. Countries including Nigeria, Senegal, Ivory Coast, Mali, Burkina Faso, Tanzania, Tunisia, Cape Verde, Botswana and Chad say they would want to continue being in the ICC.

At the February summit in Addis Ababa, the AU also agreed to push for reforms at the UN Security Council. No African country is a permanent member on the council which can refer cases to the ICC even though the court is not a UN court.

Speaking on World Affairs hosted by Dr Etse Sikanku on Class91.3FM about the ICC’s work vis-à-vis Africa, Mr Short, who served twice as a Judge on the Rwanda Tribunal in Arusha, Tanzania, said: “When you look at the African Union wanting to pull out of the International Criminal Court (ICC), that is a situation, which I think a lot of people don’t understand the real facts behind the issue. And I find it distressing that many people are supporting that decision because it is only going to leave innocent African victims without justice.”

Mr Short said as “a court of last resort,” the ICC “can only intervene in national situations where the national jurisdictions are unable or unwilling to investigate and prosecute those crimes. If national jurisdictions have the ability and the willingness to handle the crime, the ICC doesn’t come in at all.”

In his observation, the AU and Africans think the ICC is targeting the continent because all the cases currently pending before it have to do with African countries.

“Now there are nine cases before the court involving eight African countries, so almost all the cases before the court are from Africa, and, therefore, it sort of gets people to feel that ICC is targeting Africa but this is not the case. In five of those situations involving four countries, the African countries themselves referred the cases to the ICC. The African countries said: ‘We cannot handle these cases, decide these cases for us’: Mali, Uganda, Democratic Republic of Congo and Central African Republic.’ In two of the cases, it’s the UN Security Council that referred the cases to the ICC; that is Kenya and Libya … so, you have seven situations where the ICC had no hand in the investigations, and, so, when you take all of these facts into consideration, the allegation that the ICC is targeting the African countries is a misconception.”

Mr Short, the first Commissioner of Ghana’s ombudsman Commission on Human Rights and Administrative Justice (CHRAJ), said rather than the AU fighting the ICC, its members must direct their energies at pushing for reforms within the UN Security Council so as to make the five permanent members liable to the ICC.

“What the AU and the African countries should be talking about is the fact that the big powers: Russia, USA, China and so on, have failed to ratify the Rome statue and are, therefore, trying to escape accountability from the ICC. We should focus on that and put pressure on them to ratify the Rome statute, so they also become liable to the court. We should also be working at reforming the Security Council because what is happening at the Security Council is that the five permanent members, each one has a veto, and, therefore, they could prevent any of these big powers from being referred to the ICC. So, that is the injustice which we should be addressing. … It’s not about the ICC targeting Africa but most of all, I think this is what we should understand, the ICC was set up for innocent victims who do not get justice from their own countries, and, therefore, the ICC has been set up as a last resort so that they could provide justice for these innocent victims.”

credit:classfmonline

Publish on Apt

Do you have any Social, informational, educational or entertaining stuff that should be featured on www.aptnewsghana.com?

Please submit your stories, pictures, and videos to us via WhatsApp: +233548388489 or click on the icon on your screen. Alternatively, email us: aptnewsghana@gmail.com

RSS APO Group – Africa-Newsroom: latest news releases related to Africa

  • How solid states beat hard choices - and why the financial sector is implementing all-flash storage (By Sphumelele Ndlovu) September 21, 2021
    Download logoBy Sphumelele Ndlovu We are living through a fourth industrial revolution, led by a mix of emerging technologies. This shift means that financial services providers will have to rethink the way they operate to deliver new value for all stakeholders. Business leaders and ICT experts from Eastern Africa and the globe will convene Sep […]
  • Promoting Inclusive Financial Services to Build a Fully Connected, Digital World (By Li Xianhui) September 21, 2021
    By Li Xianhui, Global Financial Services Business Unit, Huawei Enterprise BG (https://e.Huawei.com) As digital technologies, the Internet, and mobile communications become more integrated with the financial services industry, financial transaction modes and service models are evolving. Digital, mobile, and intelligent financial inclusion have become significant trends. At the 2016 G20 Hangzhou Summit, the concept of […]
  • Unlocking Investments into Africa's Renewable Energy Market September 21, 2021
    Download logoThe African Energy Guarantee Facility (AEGF) is launching a virtual roadshow of free webinars allowing a deeper understanding of risk issues for renewable energy projects on the continent, and conversations around risk mitigation solutions. The first webinar will take place on Thursday, 23 September from 14:30-16:00 hrs. EAT. Please click here (https://bit.ly/3CyCtgo) to register for the […]
  • Partnership for data-driven early response to hunger launched September 21, 2021
    [youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lMb7HjtAUaU&w=854&h=480]Leading research and humanitarian agencies have joined forces to harness data and technology in a bid to stop climate shocks resulting in hunger in vulnerable livestock farming communities. The Jameel Observatory for Food Security Early Action is being created to help tackle the growing threat to people in the world’s drylands posed by the […]
  • Resilience and recovery: Africa's complex pandemic recovery will be shaped by how its governments respond to innovation in healthcare, mounting debt pressures, and regional insecurity against the geopolitical backdrop of a recalibration of relations with the rest of the world September 21, 2021
    Leading global specialist risk consultancy, Control Risks (www.ControlRisks.com), and Oxford Economics Africa, announced the launch of the sixth edition of their Africa Risk-Reward Index today. The Africa Risk-Reward Index is an authoritative guide for policymakers, business leaders and investors.  The report monitors developments in the investment landscape in major African markets and delivers a grounded, […]
  • Trading robots - how effective are they? September 21, 2021
    Emotional attachment, more commonly referred to as emotional trading, is one of the most detrimental contributors to an online trader's profitability and overall market success. Emotions such as fear, greed, hope and frustration, can cause traders to think irrationally and often result in increased risk and making the wrong trading decisions. It is for this […]
  • Canon partners with the United Nations for the Global Week to #Act4SDGs, to educate and inspire the next generation to become active changemakers September 21, 2021
    Canon (www.Canon-CNA.com), a global provider of imaging technologies and services, is partnering with the United Nations to take part in the Global Week to #Act4SDGs from the 17th – 28th September. Canon will showcase its commitments to the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), as well as featuring in the UN’s ‘Turning Point Dialogue’ interview series […]
  • U.S. Travel Restrictions Lifted; Move Welcomed by Energy Industry September 21, 2021
    The United States will lift restrictions on air travelers from 33 countries from November, the White House announced on Monday. Energy Capital & Power (ECP) (www.EnergyCapitalPower.com), organizer of the U.S.-Africa Energy Forum (USAEF), and the African Energy Chamber, host of the African Energy Week in Cape Town, welcome the news. Current bans on travel from […]
  • Launch of the 2021 Edition of the Africa Risk-Reward Index September 21, 2021
    [youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_bDT4SlIg7I&w=854&h=480]Leading global specialist risk consultancy, Control Risks, and Oxford Economics Africa, will launch their sixth edition of their Africa Risk-Reward Index. We have a global team of Africa experts available to share their insights and views on Africa’s post-pandemic recovery and the key themes featured in the 2021 report. Distributed by APO Group on […]
  • Saloodo! rolls out new "Closed Shop" feature September 21, 2021
    The logistics start-up Saloodo! (www.Saloodo.com) has integrated a new feature into its freight platform that makes it even easier for shippers to find perfectly matching carriers for their transport needs. With the "Closed Shop" feature, companies can now offer their transport orders to pre-selected transport service providers on demand - worldwide. "At Saloodo! we are […]